# Solid shaft

**URL:** <https://forum.syncro.com.au/t/solid-shaft/67>\
**Category:** Uncategorized\
**Created:** [23 October 2007 11:42 UTC](https://forum.syncro.com.au/t/solid-shaft/67 "2007-10-23T11:42:01Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 9\
**Page:** 1

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![unclekenz](https://forum.syncro.com.au/user_avatar/forum.syncro.com.au/unclekenz/32/33_2.png) [@unclekenz](https://forum.syncro.com.au/u/unclekenz)\
**Post date:** [23 October 2007 11:42 UTC](https://forum.syncro.com.au/t/solid-shaft/67/1 "2007-10-23T11:42:01Z")

</div>

Gday ALL,  
Well I finally arrived back home last weekend after 7 weeks away in the   
Syncro. Five weeks ago I saw in the flesh for the first time .. a   
viscous coupling, namely mine! Weighing in at around 8kg, I've now re-  
deployed it as a doorstop and/or conversation piece. Could also be   
useful for muscle building in a home gym.   
  
So I'm just wondering if there is anyone else we know of in Oz who has   
also switched to a solid shaft? Be worthwhile to compare notes.  
  
Any responses would be appreciated. Cheers all.  
Ken

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![pootaguru](https://forum.syncro.com.au/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/p/46a35a/32.png) [@pootaguru](https://forum.syncro.com.au/u/pootaguru)\
**Post date:** [23 October 2007 14:37 UTC](https://forum.syncro.com.au/t/solid-shaft/67/2 "2007-10-23T14:37:31Z")

</div>

Hey Ken  
  
From memory Rudi had one.  
  
Sam  
  

> --- In [Syncro\_T3\_Australia@yahoogroups.com](mailto:Syncro_T3_Australia@yahoogroups.com), "Ken" \<unclekenz@...\> wrote:  
> \>  
> \> Gday ALL,  
> \> Well I finally arrived back home last weekend after 7 weeks away in the   
> \> Syncro. Five weeks ago I saw in the flesh for the first time .. a   
> \> viscous coupling, namely mine! Weighing in at around 8kg, I've now re-  
> \> deployed it as a doorstop and/or conversation piece. Could also be   
> \> useful for muscle building in a home gym.   
> \>   
> \> So I'm just wondering if there is anyone else we know of in Oz who has   
> \> also switched to a solid shaft? Be worthwhile to compare notes.  
> \>   
> \> Any responses would be appreciated. Cheers all.  
> \> Ken  
> \>

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![bentbutstr8](https://forum.syncro.com.au/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/b/5fc32e/32.png) [@bentbutstr8](https://forum.syncro.com.au/u/bentbutstr8)\
**Post date:** [23 October 2007 20:05 UTC](https://forum.syncro.com.au/t/solid-shaft/67/3 "2007-10-23T20:05:43Z")

</div>

> On 10/23/07, **Ken** \<[unclekenz@yahoo.com](mailto:unclekenz@yahoo.com)\> wrote:
> 
> > Gday ALL,  
> > Well I finally arrived back home last weekend after 7 weeks away in the  
> > Syncro. Five weeks ago I saw in the flesh for the first time .. a  
> > viscous coupling, namely mine! Weighing in at around 8kg, I've now re-  
> > deployed it as a doorstop and/or conversation piece. Could also be  
> > useful for muscle building in a home gym.  
> >   
> > So I'm just wondering if there is anyone else we know of in Oz who has  
> > also switched to a solid shaft? Be worthwhile to compare notes.  
> >   
> > Any responses would be appreciated. Cheers all.  
> > Ken
> 
> &nbsp;
> 
> &nbsp;
> 
> I take it solid shaft plus a decoupler, right? Otherwise it may not be the most fun ride with just the solid shaft in place of the VC.
> 
> &nbsp;
> 
> BenT
>   
> 
> > Yahoo! Groups Links  
> >   
> > \<\*\> To visit your group on the web, go to:  
> > &nbsp;&nbsp; [http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Syncro\_T3\_Australia/](http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Syncro_T3_Australia/)  
> >   
> > \<\*\> Your email settings:  
> > &nbsp;&nbsp; Individual Email | Traditional  
> >   
> > \<\*\> To change settings online go to:  
> > &nbsp;&nbsp; [http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Syncro\_T3\_Australia/join](http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Syncro_T3_Australia/join)  
> > &nbsp;&nbsp; (Yahoo! ID required)  
> >   
> > \<\*\> To change settings via email:  
> > &nbsp;&nbsp; mailto:[Syncro\_T3\_Australia-digest@yahoogroups.com](mailto:Syncro_T3_Australia-digest@yahoogroups.com)  
> > &nbsp;&nbsp; mailto:[Syncro\_T3\_Australia-fullfeatured@yahoogroups.com](mailto:Syncro_T3_Australia-fullfeatured@yahoogroups.com)  
> >   
> > \<\*\> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:  
> > &nbsp;&nbsp; [Syncro\_T3\_Australia-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com](mailto:Syncro_T3_Australia-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com)  
> >   
> > \<\*\> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:  
> > &nbsp;&nbsp; [http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/](http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/)
> 
>    
>   
>   
> --   
> BenT

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![syncroaustralia](https://forum.syncro.com.au/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/s/e9a140/32.png) [@syncroaustralia](https://forum.syncro.com.au/u/syncroaustralia)\
**Post date:** [23 October 2007 22:47 UTC](https://forum.syncro.com.au/t/solid-shaft/67/4 "2007-10-23T22:47:54Z")

</div>

Ken,

&nbsp;

This subject has been very thoroughly covered on the world's Syncro sites.&nbsp; Are you also running a decoupler or is it just a solid shaft replacing the VC?&nbsp; If it is a solid shaft on its own, DON'T EVER&nbsp;run it on dry bitumen.&nbsp; You will destroy the entire drive train very rapidly because the front and rear axles will be running at the same speed.&nbsp; Every change of direction, however slight, results in the two axles running at different speeds.&nbsp; If they are prevented from doing so by a solid shaft, the load on the entire drive train is immense and immensely expensive breakages always follow.&nbsp; Even on gravel, a solid shaft runs second to a VC functioning normally.&nbsp; The only situation in which the solid shaft will out-perform the VC, and this is anecdotal evidence drawn from many of the world's Syncro websites, is in deep sand.

&nbsp;

Les

&nbsp;

> > ----- Original Message ----- 
> > 
> > **From:** [Ken](mailto:unclekenz@yahoo.com "unclekenz@yahoo.com") 
> > 
> > **To:** [Syncro\_T3\_Australia@yahoogroups.com](mailto:Syncro_T3_Australia@yahoogroups.com "Syncro\_T3\_Australia@yahoogroups.com")
> > 
> > **Sent:** Tuesday, October 23, 2007 9:42 PM
> > 
> > **Subject:** [Syncro\_T3\_Australia] Solid shaft
> > 
> >   
> > 
> > Gday ALL,  
> > Well I finally arrived back home last weekend after 7 weeks away in the   
> > Syncro. Five weeks ago I saw in the flesh for the first time .. a   
> > viscous coupling, namely mine! Weighing in at around 8kg, I've now re-  
> > deployed it as a doorstop and/or conversation piece. Could also be   
> > useful for muscle building in a home gym.   
> >   
> > So I'm just wondering if there is anyone else we know of in Oz who has   
> > also switched to a solid shaft? Be worthwhile to compare notes.  
> >   
> > Any responses would be appreciated. Cheers all.  
> > Ken

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![bentbutstr8](https://forum.syncro.com.au/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/b/5fc32e/32.png) [@bentbutstr8](https://forum.syncro.com.au/u/bentbutstr8)\
**Post date:** [24 October 2007 00:01 UTC](https://forum.syncro.com.au/t/solid-shaft/67/5 "2007-10-24T00:01:05Z")

</div>

> On 10/23/07, **Les Harris** \<[leslieharris@optushome.com.au](mailto:leslieharris@optushome.com.au)\> wrote:
> 
> > Ken,
> > 
> > &nbsp;
> > 
> > This subject has been very thoroughly covered on the world's Syncro sites.&nbsp; Are you also running a decoupler or is it just a solid shaft replacing the VC?&nbsp; If it is a solid shaft on its own, DON'T EVER&nbsp;run it on dry bitumen.&nbsp; You will destroy the entire drive train very rapidly because the front and rear axles will be running at the same speed.&nbsp; Every change of direction, however slight, results in the two axles running at different speeds.&nbsp; If they are prevented from doing so by a solid shaft, the load on the entire drive train is immense and immensely expensive breakages always follow.&nbsp; Even on gravel, a solid shaft runs second to a VC functioning normally.&nbsp; The only situation in which the solid shaft will out-perform the VC, and this is anecdotal evidence drawn from many of the world's Syncro websites, is in deep sand.
> > 
> > &nbsp;
> > 
> > Les
> 
> &nbsp;
> 
> &nbsp;
> 
> Les,
> 
> &nbsp;
> 
> It's fabulous on 100% grades too. That's not saying a properly powered Syncro with a VC can't do it but I have seen & riden in both types in the same afternoon. The solid shaft equipped rig just went straight up the hill w/o a burp. The VC equipped Syncros had to&nbsp;choose a&nbsp;more deliberate path to keep from slipping backwards. Nevertheless, I prefer the VC in my Syncro 16 for the&nbsp;more useful flexibility&nbsp;in all types of weather.&nbsp;
> 
> &nbsp;
> 
> Note&nbsp;that here in&nbsp;US,&nbsp;it is not unsual to drive several hundred miles of pavement&nbsp;to go to a proper&nbsp;Syncro playgrounds.&nbsp;Solid shaft or not, a decoupler can be quite handy to get you home should you have tire problems or have a broken CV/axle on one end. 
> 
> &nbsp;
> 
> &nbsp;
> 
> Cheers,
> 
> &nbsp;
> 
> BenT
> 
> &nbsp;
> 
> &nbsp;
>   
> &nbsp;

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![unclekenz](https://forum.syncro.com.au/user_avatar/forum.syncro.com.au/unclekenz/32/33_2.png) [@unclekenz](https://forum.syncro.com.au/u/unclekenz)\
**Post date:** [24 October 2007 10:42 UTC](https://forum.syncro.com.au/t/solid-shaft/67/6 "2007-10-24T10:42:43Z")

</div>

Sam,  
  
yes well thanks, but I think all of us who went to Batemens Bay know  
that. I mean anyone else ok? Add one to your shopping list too Sam ..  
haha. Cheers.  
  
Ken  
  
  
--- In [Syncro\_T3\_Australia@yahoogroups.com](mailto:Syncro_T3_Australia@yahoogroups.com), "heysamuelarnold" \<me@...\>  
wrote:  

> \>  
> \> Hey Ken  
> \>  
> \> From memory Rudi had one.  
> \>  
> \> Sam  
> \>  
> \> --- In [Syncro\_T3\_Australia@yahoogroups.com](mailto:Syncro_T3_Australia@yahoogroups.com), "Ken" unclekenz@ wrote:  
> \> \>  
> \> \> Gday ALL,  
> \> \> Well I finally arrived back home last weekend after 7 weeks away in

the  

> \> \> Syncro. Five weeks ago I saw in the flesh for the first time .. a  
> \> \> viscous coupling, namely mine! Weighing in at around 8kg, I've now

re-  

> \> \> deployed it as a doorstop and/or conversation piece. Could also be  
> \> \> useful for muscle building in a home gym.  
> \> \>  
> \> \> So I'm just wondering if there is anyone else we know of in Oz who

has  

> \> \> also switched to a solid shaft? Be worthwhile to compare notes.  
> \> \>  
> \> \> Any responses would be appreciated. Cheers all.  
> \> \> Ken  
> \> \>  
> \>

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![unclekenz](https://forum.syncro.com.au/user_avatar/forum.syncro.com.au/unclekenz/32/33_2.png) [@unclekenz](https://forum.syncro.com.au/u/unclekenz)\
**Post date:** [25 October 2007 13:41 UTC](https://forum.syncro.com.au/t/solid-shaft/67/7 "2007-10-25T13:41:40Z")

</div>

Gday BenT and Les and ALL,  
  
Sorry guys but I deliberately didn't mention in my first post about the  
decoupler as I believed it to be assumed knowledge by attentive readers  
that anyone who has a solid shaft would automatically have a decoupler,  
hence no need for me at that stage to mention it nor to be asked about  
it. In my research, I've certainly not read anywhere to the contrary  
either.  
  
My view on the pros and cons of VC v solid shaft are adequately  
documented on this forum. As well, it makes sense to me that syncro  
owners would not need to address this particular issue until such time  
as their VC became defunct, as in my case. As an aside though, it was  
testament to my syncro that I breezed through most of the Batemans Bay  
2007 Syncro Tour in 2WD only + G gear. I just lurv the G gear!  
  
Having participated in and read ad nauseum the for and against theories  
expressed here and elsewhere on this topic, I came to the conclusion  
that for the VC and SS alternatives, both have numerous but different  
advantages and disadvantages. For me, it came down to what I prioritised  
as most important and also added to the mix such considerations as how  
and where I drive and what my needs are for this vehicle, the SS came  
out tops, despite the added initial cost for the decoupler.  
  
I also had the benefit of being talked through the alternatives one on  
one with Rudi, arguably in my view Australias foremost and experienced  
hands-on mechanic for the syncro drivetrain components in particular. It  
would take a very brave or else foolhardy person to disagree with that  
statement. Anyone who hasn't dealt with Rudi I suggest has no idea of  
what I'm talking about. The east coast of Oz is indeed very fortunate to  
have him, virtually on their doorstep. And a nice bloke to boot.  
  
So now, compared with how my 2WD + G gear syncro was before, the  
transformation is quite incredible. Now with a solid shaft plus  
decoupler plus rear difflock, the instant responsiveness, surefootedness  
and smoothness off-road is very rewarding and reassuring. Nevertheless,  
I am aware of and do accept the need for discipline and caution in the  
judicious use of this SS system, certainly NOT on bitumen/grippy  
surfaces.  
  
My only regret is I didn't have these mods done sooner, it certainly  
would have saved me some angst. And to keep it all in perspective, I  
reiterate what I've said on a previous occasion, it is my own preference  
and intention to continue driving as I always have done, predominantly  
in 2WD. Now I, not the machine, will decide when and where the need  
arises to engage 4WD, in similar way as for judiciously engaging the  
rear diflock.  
  
In conclusion, may I suggest that for the benefit of all interested  
syncro owners in Australia and our syncro knowledge base, there may now  
be the opportunity on future syncro tours to carry out A-B off-road  
performance comparisons between VC and SS equipped vehicles. Mind you,  
I'm aware of only 2 x SS syncros in Australia at the moment that  
could participate. The question remains then, are there any more SS  
syncros around? Maybe we need another register to keep track of such.  
  
Cheers BenT and Les and ALL,  
  
Ken  
  
  
--- In [Syncro\_T3\_Australia@yahoogroups.com](mailto:Syncro_T3_Australia@yahoogroups.com), "BenT Syncro" \<syncro@...\>  
wrote:  

> \>  
> \> On 10/23/07, Les Harris leslieharris@... wrote:  
> \> \>  
> \> \> Ken,  
> \> \>  
> \> \> This subject has been very thoroughly covered on the world's Syncro  
> \> \> sites. Are you also running a decoupler or is it just a solid shaft  
> \> \> replacing the VC? If it is a solid shaft on its own, DON'T EVER run

it on  

> \> \> dry bitumen. You will destroy the entire drive train very rapidly

because  

> \> \> the front and rear axles will be running at the same speed. Every

change of  

> \> \> direction, however slight, results in the two axles running at

different  

> \> \> speeds. If they are prevented from doing so by a solid shaft, the

load on  

> \> \> the entire drive train is immense and immensely expensive breakages

always  

> \> \> follow. Even on gravel, a solid shaft runs second to a VC

functioning  

> \> \> normally. The only situation in which the solid shaft will

out-perform the  

> \> \> VC, and this is anecdotal evidence drawn from many of the world's

Syncro  

> \> \> websites, is in deep sand.  
> \> \>  
> \> \> Les  
> \> \>  
> \>  
> \>  
> \> Les,  
> \>  
> \> It's fabulous on 100% grades too. That's not saying a properly powered  
> \> Syncro with a VC can't do it but I have seen & riden in both types in

the  

> \> same afternoon. The solid shaft equipped rig just went straight up the

hill  

> \> w/o a burp. The VC equipped Syncros had to choose a more deliberate

path to  

> \> keep from slipping backwards. Nevertheless, I prefer the VC in my

Syncro 16  

> \> for the more useful flexibility in all types of weather.  
> \>  
> \> Note that here in US, it is not unsual to drive several hundred miles

of  

> \> pavement to go to a proper Syncro playgrounds. Solid shaft or not, a  
> \> decoupler can be quite handy to get you home should you have tire

problems  

> \> or have a broken CV/axle on one end.  
> \>  
> \>  
> \> Cheers,  
> \>  
> \> BenT  
> \>

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![m.mullet](https://forum.syncro.com.au/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/m/e9c0ed/32.png) [@m.mullet](https://forum.syncro.com.au/u/m.mullet)\
**Post date:** [13 August 2009 12:30 UTC](https://forum.syncro.com.au/t/solid-shaft/67/8 "2009-08-13T12:30:53Z")

</div>

| Interesting series of posts with everyone having an opinion. Most interesting I find is that VW  
engineered a decoupler into the equation before discontinuing it.  
Under advice from my then mechanic I had a decoupler fitted in 2005. The advice being that the drivetrain would last longer without the stress of bitumen use. It is much better to drive around town, with none of the extra loading you feel ( and rattling under torque when propshaft bushes are worn ) when in AWD.  
I must point out that I have an aggressive VC and I find the combination about right. As a 4WD it works very well - with a diff lock and a bit more ground clearance.  
I can't imagine a solid shaft offering a significant improvement considering the risk to the drivetrain.   
  
Regards  
  
Mark Hallett  
  
  
 |

  

* * *
Find local businesses and services in your area with Yahoo!7 Local. [Get started](https://forum.syncro.com.au/ http://au.rd.yahoo.com/search/local/mailtagline/*http://local.yahoo.com.au).

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![do5oy](https://forum.syncro.com.au/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/d/977dab/32.png) [@do5oy](https://forum.syncro.com.au/u/do5oy)\
**Post date:** [13 August 2009 13:43 UTC](https://forum.syncro.com.au/t/solid-shaft/67/9 "2009-08-13T13:43:29Z")

</div>

On 13.08.2009, at 14:30, mark hallett wrote:  
  

> \> I can't imagine a solid shaft offering a significant improvement   
> \> considering the risk to the drivetrain.

Oh it does offer an advantage in Sand, there is no doubt about that.   
It's just so hard to imagine that daily drive from home to work   
through serious dunes..... :)  
  
.martin  
  
  
--  
Martin Henning, DM5OY  
[martin@easy2design.de](mailto:martin@easy2design.de)  
[http://log.tigerbus.de](http://log.tigerbus.de)
